Q1. Why is Bethesda expanding and Walter Reed closing?
The proposed changes
are the result of the BRAC recommendations, which became law on November
8, 2005. Specifically, the Medical Joint Cross-Service Group (JCSG)
was chartered to review Department of Defense health care functions
and to provide base closure and realignment (BRAC) recommendations based
on that review. After review, their recommendation was to realign Walter
Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, DC, by relocating all tertiary
(sub-specialty and complex care) medical services to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center
, Bethesda, MD, establishing it as the Walter Reed National
Military Medical Center (WRNMMC), Bethesda, MD
Military health
care services in the National Capital Area will no longer operate in
an independent fashion in order to maximize efficiency and support the
war fighter. The vision for the future is an integrated health care
delivery system acting as a network of health care providers and component
facilities that provide and arrange coordinated ambulatory and inpatient
services to the area's beneficiary population. In addition, the way
ahead includes a strong component of joint Graduate Medical Education.
Facilities included in this regionalized military medical system also
include Malcolm Grow Medical Center, DeWitt Army Community Hospital,
and the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences.
Q2. Why
does the military need its own hospitals?
Military medicine
plays a critical role in supporting the United States Armed Forces.
Our primary job is to support the war fighter no matter what the environment.
In order to support our service members wherever they deploy, it is
critical for our medical providers to have the full complement of skills
to treat illness and injury, both here and abroad, including in the
deployed environment. Military treatment facilities allow them to hone
their skills and abilities to meet the unique needs of the military
services. These skills are not readily obtainable at civilian institutions.
Q3. What
operations will be supported at the new WRNMMC?
The WRNMMC is slated
to be an approximately 345-bed Medical Center with the full range of
intensive and complex specialty and subspecialty medical services, including
specialized facilities for the most seriously war injured. This facility
will serve as the U. S. military’s worldwide tertiary referral
center for casualty and beneficiary care.
Q4. What
will the project look like?
The final project design
is still being developed at this time to meet the needs of the mission
in the future. The aesthetic look of the enhanced WRNMMC facility will
respect the WRNMMC Tower’s current status on the National Register
of Historic Places.
In order to identify the
space and equipment requirements for the future WRNMMC, functional teams
of staff members have been collaborating with contractors over the past
year to ensure the architectural and engineering designs will create
an efficient clinical layout and work environment. The current estimate
calls for approximately 2,400,000 square feet of new or renovated space
at the WRNMMC campus to support BRAC-mandated actions.
Q5. How
will the design be selected?
A decision will
be made by the Department of the Defense based on cost, expected performance,
and environmental and other impacts as disclosed in the Environmental
Impact Statement (EIS) process. There will be substantial opportunity
for public input to the EIS.
Q6. Where
is the project located?
The project is located
on the grounds of the current Walter Reed National Military Medical Center
campus in
Bethesda, MD. This site is currently comprised of 243 acres and 88 buildings.
Q7. Isn’t
there any other location to support this enhanced mission, like Malcolm
Grow on Andrews Air Force base?
The military medical
system throughout the NCA will be realigned based upon the BRAC recommendations.
We anticipate this realigned system of military medical facilities will
bring some additional traffic and visitors to Bethesda; however, it
will also disperse visits by our beneficiaries throughout the region.
In addition to the
integration of WRAMC and WRNMMC, the medical capabilities at DeWitt Army
Community Hospital at Fort Belvoir, VA will also be enhanced. DeWitt
is slated to grow in both physical size and capabilities, which will
result in a more balanced military health system in the NCA. This expansion
will allow our beneficiaries who currently come to WRNMMC or WRAMC for
care to stay closer to home in Northern Virginia.
Q8. Who
currently owns the Bethesda campus?
The Bethesda campus
is currently owned by the Department of the Navy.
Q9. How
long will it take to build?
All BRAC-related
construction is mandated to be completed by September 15, 2011 in accordance
with BRAC law. Major construction cannot begin prior to the completion
of the EIS. Once the EIS is finalized and designs are completed, construction
can begin. Additional construction of facilities not directed by BRAC
may continue beyond 2011.
Q10. Will
the project mean more staff and visitors at the Bethesda campus?
Yes, though the exact number
has yet to be determined. The outcome of the EIS process will help determine
final structure of both buildings and personnel at the Bethesda campus.
The EIS is considering two
action alternatives for construction of BRAC-mandated facilities, as
well as support facilities not funded through BRAC. The EIS alternatives
currently assume the addition of approximately 2,200 new employees at
WRNMMC by 2011. However, to remain within the limits as published in the
Notice of Intent (NOI) to prepare an EIS, the greatest number of additional
personnel that could be added to the Bethesda campus would be approximately
2,500.
Since the mission of WRNMMC
will grow, we also expect to see a proportional increase in patients
and visitors to the Bethesda campus.
Q11. What
is the proposed WRNMMC project cost?
Estimates for the total cost
of construction and renovation are still being refined but current estimates
indicate the military construction and renovation portion of the project
will be approximately $900,000,000. Additionally the Fisher Foundation
will be funding the construction of two new Fishers Houses to support
wounded veterans and their families.
Q12. How
many jobs will be created by this project?
Approximately 2,200 staff
will be added to the Bethesda campus. Most of the new personnel added
to the future WRNMMC facility will transfer from other DoD locations.
Some short-term jobs may be created in the construction industry once
we begin physical building and renovations.
Q13. Will
the project create any additional long-term jobs in Bethesda?
Most of the jobs
added to the realigned WRNMMC facility will come through transfers.
For example, a large number of new staff will come to WRNMMC from WRAMC
and some will be Air Force staff from across the country. Some new jobs
may be created in the process but the percentage will be small in comparison
to the overall number of new staff.
Q14. What
is the purpose of an EIS?
An EIS is a systematic,
interdisciplinary evaluation of the consequences of a proposed Federal
action. The purpose of an EIS is to inform the decision-maker of the
impacts of the proposed action on the human and natural environments,
and to “ensure that environmental information is available to
public officials and citizens before decisions are made and before actions
are taken” (Council on Environmental Quality Regulations 1500.1).
An EIS is required
for Federal actions that meet certain criteria, which in general are
those with potential for significant impacts on the environment. Significance
is determined by the relative geographical extent of the proposed action’s
effects, their duration, the risks posed, and the value or scarcity
of the resources affected (human health and safety, historical resources,
or endangered species for example).
Q15. How
can I voice my opinion about the project?
The EIS process
is inherently a public process. There will be three opportunities for
the public to share concerns and participate: 1.) During the scoping
process where the public is encouraged to identify potential impacts
of particular concern. 2.) After publication of the Draft EIS, comments
on the adequacy and scope of coverage of the draft are solicited. 3.)
After publication of the Final EIS. Even though the document says “Final”
the comments will be useful in preparing the record of decision, so
it will not be too late to have an impact on the decision making process.
Public Notices alert
interested citizens about the specific times as follows:
Scoping
- During scoping, which for the WRNMMC project took place in Fall 2006,
interested parties submitted comments on the scope of issues that should
be studied in detail in the EIS.
During scoping,
the Navy coordinated with other government agencies, and held six public
meetings to inform people of the proposed project. Public comments were
submitted in writing during the public meetings as well as via email
and mail.
Draft
EIS Public Review Period - Following scoping, a Draft EIS
(DEIS) was prepared. The DEIS evaluates the significance of potential
impacts of the proposed action, and compares the impacts of various
project alternatives, which must include a “No Action” alternative.
This document has been made public, and the public has 45 days, known
as the DEIS Comment Period, to comment on the adequacy of the DEIS,
or the merits of the various alternatives, or both. Every substantive
comment must receive a response, either by changing factual material
in the EIS, revising or adding analysis, modifying or adding alternatives,
or explaining why such changes are not warranted.
For the WRNMMC project, the
DEIS Public Review period was initiated on December 14, 2007 with the
publication of the Notice of Availability (NOA) and the Notice of Public
Hearings (NOPH) in the Federal Register. January 28, 2008 marks the
end of the 45-day public review and comment period. During the Draft
EIS public review period, the Navy held two public hearings, where it
received oral as well as written comments from the public.
Until January 28, 2008,
the Navy is accepting comments by E-Mail at WRNMMCEIS@med.navy.mil,
by Fax at: (301) 295-5020 or by Mail at:
Officer in Charge –
BRAC
DEIS Comments
Walter Reed National Military Medical Center
8901 Wisconsin Avenue
Bethesda, Maryland 20889
Final
EIS Public Review - The Final EIS (FEIS) is a revised version
of the DEIS, and must include responses to public comments received
on the DEIS. Following its publication, for which notice is made in
the Federal Register and in local newspapers, there is a final 30- day
Wait Period (no action period) before a Record of Decision (ROD) is
published.
Q16.
When will the comment
period for the Draft EIS end?
Midnight January 28, 2008
marks the end of the 45-day public review and comment period for the
Draft EIS for the WRNMMC project.
Q17. How and when
we can expect a response to my comments on the Draft EIS?
Responses to comments received
on the Draft EIS are required to be included in the Final EIS, which
is currently scheduled for publication in April 2008.
Q18. Why
does an EIS take so long?
The EIS process
for the WRNMMC project is expected to take 12-18 months, from Notice of
Intent to Prepare the EIS in Fall 2006 to Record of Decision in early
to mid 2008. This time is spent in several ways. First, investigations
of the physical environment are conducted and environmental studies
are addressed in areas that may be affected. Then, for the public input
process, the draft EIS is compiled and circulated for comment, followed
by further revisions in the FEIS and further comment. This all takes
time.
Coordination with
Federal, State, and Local regulators occurs during this entire period.
Coordination of studies and review of results also occurs during this
period. All parties depend on information that others collect and analyze,
and then transfer. Ensuring that this information is available and of
acceptable quality requires considerable time and effort. After results
are developed, possible ways to mitigate the impacts are analyzed. Some
mitigation may be undertaken by the DoD, while some mitigation measures
would have to be undertaken by the Federal, State, or local agencies.
A lot of effort is expended in identifying mitigation measures and ensuring
that one fix does not create another unaddressed problem.
Q19. Will
the construction or operations of the new WRNMMC facility impact the
surrounding community?
Our goal throughout
the BRAC process is to minimize the disruption for visitors, staff,
and our neighbors in the community. Some level of disruption is likely
due to road projects, infrastructure improvements and physical construction
of new space necessary to support a project of this size and scope.
We hope that local community groups can help to identify potential problems
and solutions. Once construction is completed by the BRAC-mandated 2011
date, our hope is that all stakeholders will experience minimal changes
to the neighborhood and physical environment.
Q20. How
can I voice my concerns about increased traffic on local roads?
The WRNMMC BRAC team
is working closely with a number of local, county and state government
officials throughout the construction and expansion process. The Draft
EIS identifies roadways in the vicinity that would be affected by the
project and presents potential improvement measures. However, specific
questions related to traffic around the Bethesda campus should be directed
to Montgomery County and Maryland Department of Transportation officials
since they have jurisdiction over local roads.
Q21. How
can I stay informed about the project as it moves forward?
The BRAC team at
WRNMMC plans to make a continuing, concerted effort to keep visitors,
staff and the local community informed as we make progress on the upcoming
changes to our campus. The recommended means of tracking the status
is currently the NCA
Medical BRAC and Integration Web site. In addition, we will publicize
information of interest to the community through local newspapers, television
stations and radio stations.
Q22. Will the amount
of helicopter landings increase once BRAC is complete?
As of today, the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center
receives an average of approximately twelve helicopter
flights per month. Almost all of our patients arrive via ambulance,
medical evacuation bus or personally-owned vehicles. Based on data for
Walter Reed Army Medical Center, we expect an increase of only 1-2 flights
per month.
Some residents have expressed
their frustrations over helicopter traffic in this area. The area around
Bethesda frequently sees helicopter overflights by governmental, State
Police, and news helicopters; however, the vast majority of helicopter
overflights in this area are not tied to the National Naval MedicalCenter.